fbpx
  • Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • Opinions
  • Features
  • Letters
  • Videos
  • Editorials
  • Columns
Veda Nath Mohabir

Critiques Clem Seecharan on Bechu, Indian who Exposed Abuses of Indentureship

April 29, 2022
Dool Hanomansingh

Democratizing decision making in the diaspora

June 4, 2023
Ravi Balgobin Maharaj

Ravi B Maharaj of Trinidad Comments on … Clarifying Misconceptions

June 4, 2023
Jai Lall

President Irfaan of Guyana is about Humanity

June 4, 2023
ADVERTISEMENT
Paras Ramoutar

Words from laureate poem, Rabindranath Tagore resonates at 178th Indian Arrival Day in Trinidad and Tobago

June 4, 2023
Dinesh Rambally

Trinidad and Tobago Indian Arrival Day Message

June 3, 2023
Gary Griffith

Hinds throws TTPS officers in the Brent Thomas “abduction’ under the bus

June 3, 2023
New Book on Guyana

New Book on Guyana

June 3, 2023
THE SUMMER KICKS INTO HIGH GEAR WITH THE RETURN OF SAINT LUCIA CARNIVAL

THE SUMMER KICKS INTO HIGH GEAR WITH THE RETURN OF SAINT LUCIA CARNIVAL

June 3, 2023
Late Lieutenant Asap Ishoof of Guyana

Late Lieutenant Asad Ishoof of Guyana

June 3, 2023
gary-griffith

Call for Observers for Local Elections in Trinidad

June 2, 2023
Leyland-Chitlall-Roopnaraine

A CLASS ACTION LAWSUIT AGAINST THE Guyana GOV’T

June 2, 2023
Jai Lall

The 18th Chinese Medical Brigade at Leonora, Guyana

June 2, 2023
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Terms and Condition
Wednesday, June 7, 2023
  • Login
Indo Caribbean Diaspora News
  • Home
  • Columns
    Gary Griffith

    Hinds throws TTPS officers in the Brent Thomas “abduction’ under the bus

    gary-griffith

    Call for Observers for Local Elections in Trinidad

    Jai Lall

    The 18th Chinese Medical Brigade at Leonora, Guyana

    HAPPY INDIAN ARRIVAL DAY 2023 Trinidad and Tobago

    HAPPY INDIAN ARRIVAL DAY 2023 Trinidad and Tobago

    Dr. Vishnu Bisram

    Understanding US Debt Ceiling

    Gary Griffith

    Police must have militarized training to confront terrorists

    Dr. Vishnu Bisram

    India-Suriname Ties: Celebrating 150 Years

    Kamla-Persad-Bissessar

    Trinidad and Tobago Kamla on the Occasion of Indian Arrival Day

    Gary Griffith

    No Keith Rowley, it’s about results, not race in Trinidad & Tobago

    Lester Siddhartha Orie

    FCB Stole Our Weekend

  • Letters
    Jai Lall

    President Irfaan of Guyana is about Humanity

    Jai Lall

    Why is there political uneasiness in Guyana?

    Jai Lall

    Pun on Guyana’s Press Association (GPA)

    Jai Lall

    A trail of trials, traumas and tribulations

    Ravi Balgobin Maharaj

    Trinidad and Tobago Police Service Gibberish

    Leyland-Chitlall-Roopnaraine

    JUSTICE KISSOON’S DECISION PRESENTS GUYANA WITH A GOLDEN OPPORTUNITY FOR A BETTER OIL DEAL

    N.Sahadeo

    Arrival Day is Gross Disrespect to Indians in Guyana

    Jai Lall

    Freddie Kissoon, a friend of Guyana’s 

    Vassan Ramracha

    GULF STATES OIL AND GUYANA.

    Israel Khan & UNC

    Israel Khan & UNC

  • Community News
    Paras Ramoutar

    Words from laureate poem, Rabindranath Tagore resonates at 178th Indian Arrival Day in Trinidad and Tobago

    New Book on Guyana

    New Book on Guyana

    THE SUMMER KICKS INTO HIGH GEAR WITH THE RETURN OF SAINT LUCIA CARNIVAL

    THE SUMMER KICKS INTO HIGH GEAR WITH THE RETURN OF SAINT LUCIA CARNIVAL

    Late Lieutenant Asap Ishoof of Guyana

    Late Lieutenant Asad Ishoof of Guyana

    Memorial Service in Queens for Guyana Fire Victims

    Memorial Service in Queens for Guyana Fire Victims

    Guyanese grants Scholarships to Richmond Hill, Queens Students

    Guyanese grants Scholarships to Richmond Hill, Queens Students

    Veena with Judge Andrea Ogle and Judge Karen Gopee

    Showcasing the Accomplishments of Indo Caribbean Trailblazers at Queens Book Fair

    Indian Arrival in the USA

    Indian Arrival in the USA

    Lester Siddhartha Orie

    The Hindu Kennedy written by L. Siddhartha Orie

    HAPPY 90TH BIRTHDAY BASDEO PANDAY

    HAPPY 90TH BIRTHDAY BASDEO PANDAY

  • Editorials
    ANUG Meets USA Ambassador

    ANUG Meets USA Ambassador

    Jai Lall

    Guyana Govt Region 3 Outreach

    kamla-persad-bissessar

    Kamla Writes Chief Justice of Trinidad and Tobago; Slams Judge

    Ramnarine-Sahadeo

    IndIa and GIrmItIya CountrIes also Deserve Apology/Reparations

    Harry Hergash

    Is Mayor Narine preparing for APNU #2 spot in Guyana 

    Vassan Ramracha

    Response to Tacoma Ogunseye of Guyana

    Grand Turk, Turks and Caicos Islands

    Grand Turk, Turks and Caicos Islands

    Dr. Vishnu Bisram

    Dr Vishnu Bisram is the most deserving candidate for the post of High Commissioner to India

    Dr. Vishnu Bisram

    DR VISHNU BISRAM IS VERY QUALIFIED CANDIDATE FOR AMBASSADOR’S POST TO INDIA

    Jai Lall

    Assessing West Indies cricket

  • Opinions
    Dool Hanomansingh

    Democratizing decision making in the diaspora

    Ravi Balgobin Maharaj

    Ravi B Maharaj of Trinidad Comments on … Clarifying Misconceptions

    Dinesh Rambally

    Trinidad and Tobago Indian Arrival Day Message

    Leyland-Chitlall-Roopnaraine

    A CLASS ACTION LAWSUIT AGAINST THE Guyana GOV’T

    Dool Hanomansingh

    Leaders must curb their egos or perish

    Phillip Alexander

    PEP’s Indian Arrival Day Message

    Ravi Balgobin Maharaj

    Ravi Balgobin Maharaj Explains attack on Kamla

    Jai Lall

    The cost of freedom in Guyana

    Swam-Vivekananda

    A Hindu Perspective on Development

    Phillip Alexander

    Color & Rowley in Trinidad & Tobago

  • Videos
    Dool-Hanomansingh-003

    US Congress woman Tulsi Gabbard condemns the ongoing genocide of Hindus and other minorities

    Geeta-Vaahini

    Geeta Vaahini, President of the  Hindu Prachaar Kendra speaks on the social significance of Ganga Dhara Festival.

    Geeta-Vaahini

    Geeta Vaahini, President of the Hindu Prachaar Kendra speaks on the Hindu view of the environment.

    swami-brahmadeo

    Swami Brahmadeo – Hindus are top CEOs and Medics in North America and Europe

    Gowtam-Maharaj

    Gowtam Maharaj, a farmer of Barrackpore, South Trinidad, shares his challenges being a farmer.

    BAMBOO #1 Flooding – Frustrated Residents

    BAMBOO #1 Flooding – Frustrated Residents

    NATIONAL-LOTUS-THEATRE

    NATIONAL LOTUS THEATRE – Performance of Niyantran

    radica-jairam

    Story of RADICA JAIRAM from Orange Valley

    fisherman-trinidad

    Families of Orange Valley felt neglected by PNM Government

    Dr Subramanian Swamy

    Dr Subramanian Swamy – Dharma Rising London April 2015

  • Features
    Hariji

    Friends of Hariji celebrate IAD with choka and sada

    fiji-map

    Guyana’ Syria Ship Wreck off coast of Fiji

    Guyana’s Ruel Johnson Comments on Mahdia Tragedy

    Guyana’s Ruel Johnson Comments on Mahdia Tragedy

    Dr. Vishnu Bisram

    Poll Finds Show Landslide PPP Victory for June Local Elections

    Candle Light Vigil in Leonara, Guyana for Arson Fire Victims

    Candle Light Vigil in Leonara, Guyana for Arson Fire Victims

    At Reconciliation Service in Fiji

    At Reconciliation Service in Fiji

    Ravi Balgobin Maharaj

    VICTORY FOR THE PEOPLE! VICTORY FOR Trinidad & Tobago at London Privy Council

    New Civic NGO Launched in Guyana

    New Civic NGO Launched in Guyana

    ROMANCING WITH CINEMA BOOK PUBLISHING PHOTO 01

    Romancing with Girmityas

    Leyland-Chitlall-Roopnaraine

    THE E-ID IS LACED WITH INCONSISTENCIES

No Result
View All Result
Indo Caribbean Diaspora News
No Result
View All Result

Critiques Clem Seecharan on Bechu, Indian who Exposed Abuses of Indentureship

by Staff Reporter
April 29, 2022
in Features, Opinions, Uncategorized
0
Veda Nath Mohabir
3
SHARES
33
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

It might surprise readers that Prof. Clem Seecharan viewed Bachu’s writings as “partisan”. I reproduce ( in my book A Mauling of Indians, where I rebut his arguments) the following excerpts from his Moray house speech in 2014 (See link below) which triggered my book:

Seecharan’s ‘revised’ Indentured Indian story and history

An extensive excerpt of Prof Seecharan’s claims is provided so the reader could appreciate how the Indentured Indian story, history and legacy has been ‘revised’ by this acclaimed Guyanese historian to suit a Caribbean academic and lay readership – which Dr. Ramharak has concerns about over their “resistance to this Indo-centric approach”. Seecharan states:

“I was in my early thirties before I discovered that they [indentured Indian labourers] came primarily from the most impoverished part of India, virtually lawless, feudal in its social organisation and ossified by the immutability of caste prejudice. It was a stultifying environment where thuggery was commonplace. The heavy hand of the high caste landlord/money-lender aided by his goons, as I discovered a few years ago on a visit to eastern UP, has lost none of its ancient aptitude for brutal summary enforcement. (It is noteworthy that both words, “thugs‟ and “goons‟, are of Hindi derivation). Even Brahmins could become impoverished, indebted to landlords and money-lenders; besides there were many personal, domestic reasons why some – both men and women – would have wanted to flee [India]. (Italics added).’

“It is generally not known, but significant, that about two-thirds of the female indentured labourers went to Caribbean plantations on their own, unaccompanied by any relatives; 82% were aged between 10 and 30. Even more indentured men declared themselves as “single‟. There was a lot to hide.

“Amnesia and fantasy are at the fount of the construction of Indo-Guyanese identity. This was an imperative of self-preservation and the regeneration of self in the new land. Individually and collectively, not to forget the agonising reality of lives in India, blighted by famines and the loss of child-wives and child-husbands; child-wives and young widows “marooned in pitiable existence” in the homes of oppressive in-laws – a shame to return to parent’s homes – thus a “plague on both houses”; “rudderless” having been deserted by husbands who had escaped, internally or overseas, to greener pastures; consequent “infidelity‟ actuated by chronic poverty and sexual deprivation; the placelessness of widows in Hindu society – indeed, the “immemorial poverty‟ (Naipaul) of eastern Uttar Pradesh and western Bihar – was to self-destruct. Hardly any had the mental resources to accommodate such a past with a measure of equanimity; it is unconscionable to expect them to. It had to be erased by silence, but because they were all in the same boat, women and men, it was easier to navigate away from the quicksand of that unimaginably painful reality. They knew where to draw the line, not to burden each other to unmask the dark private recesses. They kept that past submerged: nothing would detach them from their cultivated amnesia. They had come to believe their silent reworking of the truth – and so have their descendants [Indo-Guyanese].

“They could absolve themselves of any responsibility for their flight, attributing total agency to the infamous arkati, the legendary, shadowy anti-hero, an unexamined folk figure of unmitigable infamy, who supposedly duped all into “a new slavery‟ and lured women in particular into a veritable narak (hell) – a constructed universe of moral depravity, rampant debauchery and unexampled degradation, on the plantations of the sugar colonies. This was not only, by and large, a distortion of conditions under indentureship; it was an ironic narrative, redolent of a displacement tactic, more reflective of eastern UP and western Bihar, whence they had fled.

“We [Indo-Guyanese] continued to wallow in the old tales of deception, kidnapping and ‘a new slavery’… they have become an armour of Indo-Guyanese identity – the badge of suffering to rival African enslavement

“Even Bechu’s fearlessly ‘partisan’ writings, in the late 1890s, on behalf of his fellow ‘bound coolies’ (which I discovered in the mid-1990s), had not sought to remedy this, although there were many thousands in British Guiana. Agency was denied the indentured labourers.

“Although Prof. Lal acknowledges that while a strand [a straw, a veritable modicum, an iota, a crumb…] of deception permeated recruitment in India, he does not see indentured women as “helpless victims” mere “pawns in the hands of unscrupulous recruiters”. He considers them “actors in their own right”; he gives agency to these women. They were mostly very young…”

Translating the latter, this author arrives at: By the Indo-Guyanese continuing to “wallow in the old tales of deception, kidnapping and ‘a new slavery’” we are denying that the indentured labourers, including “very young” girls, only ten (10) years old, made the free choice – as “actors in their own right” – to flee Mother India!

At this stage, even though recruitment will be dealt with later, Seecharan’s assertion about ‘ten year old girls” is so patently absurd that a passing comment is warranted. He wants us to believe that the young Indian women and girls – as young as ten (10) years old – were “actors in their own right” – as he puts it in another place, in a rigid “Brahminical” environment which was inimical to women! Where and how would these likely undereducated, hapless “mostly very young” women (veritable children) develop this independence of mind and courage to take flight on sailing ships, which they would have never seen, to an unknown land – several months’ journey away? These considerations go unheeded by Prof. Seecharan.

And, here is my response (p37):

Bechu partisan?

It is significant that Prof Seecharan now (via his “revisionist” perspective) refers to the literate indentured labourer, Mr. Bechu’s, letters to the press – in which he exposed the harsh and unjust treatment meted out to “his fellow ‘bound coolies’” – as “partisan” and that he ‘failed to remedy the “constructed” tales of deception, kidnapping and “a new slavery” or in Seecharan’s words: “a distortion of conditions under indentureship”.

I expect other informed historians on colonial indentureship to the West Indies, perhaps even the wider Caribbean, would be dismayed and nonplussed leading then to take issue with this characterization that Bechu was not providing a true, objective (non-“partisan”) account of the recruitment in India and the treatment of Indian labourers on the plantations. Ironically, Prof. Baytoram Ramharak wrote in the Introductory Essay to the Centenary Celebration of the Arrival of Indians to British Guiana (1838-1938):

Professor Clem Seecharan’s Bechu, “Bound Coolie” Radical in British Guiana, 1894-1901 reproduces the letters from the Daily Chronicle of an extraordinary Indian labourer who challenged the plantation system in British Guiana and exposed the evils of Indian indentureship…The numerous letters of this unsung Indian hero, and their significance in the struggle against the indenture system were brought to the public’s attention from the annals of history and carefully analyzed in this 1999 study” (p5).

Perhaps because of Prof. Seecharan’ prior confidence in Mr. Bechu, Dr. Ramharak is clearly impressed with Mr. Bechu’s championing the indentured labourers’ condition under the plantation system:

…Mr. Bechu, the radical Bengali champion of Indian indentured workers whose prolific and astutely written letters to the press exposed the injustices and immorality of the British treatment of Indians (p7).

Furthermore, Dr Ramharak is critical of those scholars who adopt the Euro-centric approach writing: “…examining that [Indian] experience from a European perspective contribute[s] to the underdevelopment of a legitimate and credible Indian historiography”. The said Eurocentric perspective permeates Seecharan’s narratives as is being revealed herein.

https://guyaneseonline.files.wordpress.com/2014/04/theeldoradocomplexintheshapingofindo-guyanese1.pdf

By Veda Mohabir

Facebook Comments Box
Tags: GuyanaGuyaneseindo-caribbeanIndo-GuyaneseTrinidadTrinidad and TobagoVeda Mohabir
Share1Tweet1Share
ADVERTISEMENT
Staff Reporter

Staff Reporter

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Phillip Alexander

PEP’s Indian Arrival Day Message

June 1, 2023
Dool Hanomansingh

Democratizing decision making in the diaspora

June 4, 2023
Hariji

Friends of Hariji celebrate IAD with choka and sada

June 2, 2023
Dr. Vishnu Bisram

India-Suriname Ties: Celebrating 150 Years

May 31, 2023
Dool Hanomansingh

Democratizing decision making in the diaspora

June 4, 2023
Ravi Balgobin Maharaj

Ravi B Maharaj of Trinidad Comments on … Clarifying Misconceptions

June 4, 2023
Jai Lall

President Irfaan of Guyana is about Humanity

June 4, 2023
Paras Ramoutar

Words from laureate poem, Rabindranath Tagore resonates at 178th Indian Arrival Day in Trinidad and Tobago

June 4, 2023

The most important world news and events of the day.

Get ICDN daily newsletter on your inbox.

ADVERTISEMENT
Indo Caribbean Diaspora News

© 2022 Indo-Caribbean Diaspora News. All rights Reserved

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Terms and Condition

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Columns
  • Letters
  • Community News
  • Opinions
  • Videos
  • Features
  • Editorials

© 2022 Indo-Caribbean Diaspora News. All rights Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In