fbpx
  • Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • Opinions
  • Features
  • Letters
  • Videos
  • Editorials
  • Columns
ravi-dev

The labour blame game

November 29, 2020
Dr. Vishnu Bisram

Guyana Schools & Public Institutions must maintain culturally inclusive environment and treat Indians with Equity

September 28, 2023
Lester Siddhartha Orie

Eulogies of the living Kamla and Rowley

September 28, 2023
Baseless Allegations against Guyana Govt in Race Focused Washington Conference

Baseless Allegations against Guyana Govt in Race Focused Washington Conference

September 28, 2023
ADVERTISEMENT
PNCR’s Grandstanding in Washington at Afro-Guyanese Meet

PNCR’s Grandstanding in Washington at Afro-Guyanese Meet

September 28, 2023
NYC Mayor Adams Graces Mandir on Gandhi Peace March

NYC Mayor Adams Graces Mandir on Gandhi Peace March

September 27, 2023
Guyana CPL 2023 Champions

Guyana CPL 2023 Champions

September 27, 2023
Urmilla Paltooram Honored for Community Work in Queens, NY

Urmilla Paltooram Honored for Community Work in Queens, NY

September 27, 2023
Ganesh Chaturthi Parade in Queens, NY

Ganesh Chaturthi Parade in Queens, NY

September 27, 2023
Pawan K Upadhyay

India to Bharat

September 27, 2023
NY Assemblywoman Honored with Gandhi Peace Prize 2023

NY Assemblywoman Honored with Gandhi Peace Prize 2023

September 26, 2023
Carib Voice Founder Speaks on Gandhi-ji, Suicide & other Social Issues

Carib Voice Founder Speaks on Gandhi-ji, Suicide & other Social Issues

September 26, 2023
Pictorials of NY Arya Samaj Gurukula Program Sept 24

Pictorials of NY Arya Samaj Gurukula Program Sept 24

September 26, 2023
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Terms and Condition
Thursday, September 28, 2023
  • Login
Indo Caribbean Diaspora News
  • Home
  • Columns
    Indo Caribbean couple shot in Trinidad; Guyanese dead

    Indo Caribbean couple shot in Trinidad; Guyanese dead

    Lester Siddhartha Orie

    Gentleman’s Game or Circus Cricket?

    Lester Siddhartha Orie

    Kumar Sanu’s Gripe

    Dr. Satish

    CELEBRATING SHRI KRISHNA JANAM ASHTAMI

    Vivian Richards Praises India landing on moon

    Vivian Richards Praises India landing on moon

    Lester Siddhartha Orie

    The Wannabe Writers

    Lester Siddhartha Orie

    My Amazon Top Pick

    Dr. Vishnu Bisram

    India’s G-20 Summit, G-7, Caricom, and Developing Countries

    Aparna Sreedhar performing at the Indian Consulate on July 2, 2023

    Indo Caribbeans at APARNA SREEDHAR MUSICAL PERFORMANCE AT INDIAN CONSULATE NY

    Lester Siddhartha Orie

    Rowley’s Endgame: The PNM’s Apocalypse

  • Letters
    Baseless Allegations against Guyana Govt in Race Focused Washington Conference

    Baseless Allegations against Guyana Govt in Race Focused Washington Conference

    Vassan Ramracha

    Indians too Suffered in Guyana

    Jai Lall

    Indian Guyanese Creolese or Dialect on Display

    Tail Wagging Dog in Guyana Gov’t Finances

    Tail Wagging Dog in Guyana Gov’t Finances

    Vassan Ramracha

    NORTON’S CALL FOR AFRICANS TO GO INTO BUSINESS IS HISTORIC

    Vassan Ramracha

    AFRICANS WERE FAR MORE SKILLED THAN iNDIANS AFTER SLAVERY

    Kamla-Persad-Bissessar

    Game over Kamla in Trinidad

    Jai Lall

    India’s Moon Landing is a giant leap

    Vassan Ramracha

    Why do Afros get Free Pass for Rights Violations of Indians

    Rabindra-Moonan

    Kamla’s Chaos and Doom

  • Community News
    NYC Mayor Adams Graces Mandir on Gandhi Peace March

    NYC Mayor Adams Graces Mandir on Gandhi Peace March

    Urmilla Paltooram Honored for Community Work in Queens, NY

    Urmilla Paltooram Honored for Community Work in Queens, NY

    Ganesh Chaturthi Parade in Queens, NY

    Ganesh Chaturthi Parade in Queens, NY

    NY Assemblywoman Honored with Gandhi Peace Prize 2023

    NY Assemblywoman Honored with Gandhi Peace Prize 2023

    Carib Voice Founder Speaks on Gandhi-ji, Suicide & other Social Issues

    Carib Voice Founder Speaks on Gandhi-ji, Suicide & other Social Issues

    Pictorials of NY Arya Samaj Gurukula Program Sept 24

    Pictorials of NY Arya Samaj Gurukula Program Sept 24

    Ganesh Chaturthi 2023 at Arya Samaj ground in Richmond Hill

    Ganesh Chaturthi 2023 at Arya Samaj ground in Richmond Hill

    Ganesh Chaturthi Observed at Tulsi Mandir, NY

    Ganesh Chaturthi Observed at Tulsi Mandir, NY

    Raksha Bandhan

    Holland’s Hague City Councilor Celebrated Raksha Bandhan

    Guyanese Visham Budhoo honored

    Guyanese Visham Budhoo honored

  • Editorials
    Vassan Ramracha

    Balance armed forces in Guyana

    Ravi Balgobin Maharaj

    Fire Minister of National Security of Trinidad and Tobago

    Leyland-Chitlall-Roopnaraine

    PUT YOUR PROMISES IN WRITING

    Mr. Rudranath Indarsingh

    INDARSINGH ON CLAIMS OF BIAS AGAINST COMMISSION

    Jai Lall

    PNC a losing party in Guyana

    Jai Lall

    Satire in Guyanese Creolese

    Jai Lall

    Words have meanings and are important

    Guyana President Speaks on apology from the Gladstone family for its involvement in African enslavement and Indian Indentureship

    Guyana President Speaks on apology from the Gladstone family for its involvement in African enslavement and Indian Indentureship

    Jai Lall

    Death and Memories

    Jai Lall

    Cooperative Effort on Bridge repairs Yield Results

  • Opinions
    Dr. Vishnu Bisram

    Guyana Schools & Public Institutions must maintain culturally inclusive environment and treat Indians with Equity

    PNCR’s Grandstanding in Washington at Afro-Guyanese Meet

    PNCR’s Grandstanding in Washington at Afro-Guyanese Meet

    Pictorials of Gandhi Peace March

    Pictorials of Gandhi Peace March

    Ravi Balgobin Maharaj

    Who Should be allowed to represent Trinidad and Tobago; Critique of Miss Grand Int’l Competition

    parmanand Sukhu Honored

    Guyanese Parmanand Sukhu Honored by Canadian Recording Studio

    Dool Hanomansingh

    Diplomacy, not flattery, will save Hindus in the diaspora

    Jaahnavi Kandula

    JUSTICE FOR INDIAN STUDENT MOWED DOWN BY POLICE IN SEATTLE

    The Vilification Versus the Vindication of Narendra Modi

    The Vilification Versus the Vindication of Narendra Modi

    Lester Siddhartha Orie

    Tobago go your way

    Former Guyana Magistrate comments on Special Trials

    Former Guyana Magistrate comments on Special Trials

  • Videos
    Dool-Hanomansingh-003

    US Congress woman Tulsi Gabbard condemns the ongoing genocide of Hindus and other minorities

    Geeta-Vaahini

    Geeta Vaahini, President of the  Hindu Prachaar Kendra speaks on the social significance of Ganga Dhara Festival.

    Geeta-Vaahini

    Geeta Vaahini, President of the Hindu Prachaar Kendra speaks on the Hindu view of the environment.

    swami-brahmadeo

    Swami Brahmadeo – Hindus are top CEOs and Medics in North America and Europe

    Gowtam-Maharaj

    Gowtam Maharaj, a farmer of Barrackpore, South Trinidad, shares his challenges being a farmer.

    BAMBOO #1 Flooding – Frustrated Residents

    BAMBOO #1 Flooding – Frustrated Residents

    NATIONAL-LOTUS-THEATRE

    NATIONAL LOTUS THEATRE – Performance of Niyantran

    radica-jairam

    Story of RADICA JAIRAM from Orange Valley

    fisherman-trinidad

    Families of Orange Valley felt neglected by PNM Government

    Dr Subramanian Swamy

    Dr Subramanian Swamy – Dharma Rising London April 2015

  • Features
    Lester Siddhartha Orie

    Eulogies of the living Kamla and Rowley

    Pawan K Upadhyay

    India to Bharat

    Lester Siddhartha Orie

    Not Cricket: It’s Waarrr

    Jai Lall

    “Madeley’s ideology scorns any apology” to Guyana President

    Indo-Caribbean Diaspora News

    Know India Program Dates

    Assemblywoman Jenifer hosts Town Hall on Public Safety

    Assemblywoman Jenifer hosts Town Hall on Public Safety

    DR-Tulsi-Dyal-Singh

    POETRY SATIRE

    Jai Lall

    Public Nominations for Guyana Democracy Awards

    CTO Chairman Kenneth Bryan with senior Caribbean and U.S. officials at the investment forum

    Call for Increased Investment in Caribbean

    Pawan Upadhyay

    Happy Hindi Diwas

No Result
View All Result
Indo Caribbean Diaspora News
No Result
View All Result

The labour blame game

by Ravi Dev
November 29, 2020
in Columns
0
ravi-dev

Photo : Ravi Dev

23
SHARES
251
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

ROAR of Ravi Dev

Ever so often I get this feeling during the 30 years I’ve returned to Guyana that I am in a time loop. Take this claim that keeps on being made by African Guyanese ideologues, that Indian indentured labourers undercut the bargaining power of the freed slaves after 1838 and that is what pushed them off the plantations. “It’s like déjà vu all over again” as Yogi Berra was alleged to have quipped.

In vain, I’ve pointed out over the years that it’s futile to play the “blame game” when, in the development of capitalism, after constructing its base on the back of African chattel slave labour (following genocide on the Indigenous Peoples), it went on to appropriate the very form of unfree labour they had used before slavery – indentured labour (of Europeans). There is no question the planters did intend to undercut the bargaining power of the freed slaves after Emancipation – but the new 19th Century indentures were also contributing to what Marx dismissed as “primitive accumulation” in the drive of capitalism to create what he ironically called “doubly free labour”: free to sell their labour-power to anyone they choose, and freed from any ownership over the means of production!

But I was just as unsuccessful in pointing out that the details of their claim were so blatantly incorrect, it suggested that more was at play than careless historiography. In 1998, I noted in my paper, “Aetiology of an Ethnic Riot”: “It was not Indian labour that broke the back of African attempts to wrest higher wages from the planters. Rather, if labour were to be “blamed”, it was more the Portuguese and, ironically, fellow Africans from both the WI and Africa, who played key roles.

The ex-slaves called the strike of 1847 at a point of financial crisis for the planters who, encouraged by the indentureship of 15,747 Portuguese, 12,897 Africans from the WI and 6957 Africans from Africa – a total of 35,601 – compared with only 8692 Indians, held off the demands for higher wages. After 1848, by when more than half of them had moved into villages and towns, the unskilled ex-slaves, by and large, decided to make their living off the plantations because, even though Indian indenture was suspended between 1838-1845 and then again in 1849-50, there was no movement back to the plantation by the Africans, nor was there any increase in the wage scale.” Available land was the pull factor for the move.

What is also overlooked is that eventually there were more indentured Africans arriving from the Caribbean (40,783) than the Portuguese (30,078) from Madeira and from Africa (13,355). In fact, between 1835 and 1838 exactly 5000 ex-African slaves had been brought from the smaller islands into Guyana. Somehow, these African indentured servants – mostly from Barbados – have been forgotten. Ironically, there were several instances recorded of Indian indentures protesting that the West Indian indentures were undercutting their wages!

I wrote to one interlocutor in 2004, “The point I have been making is that we are going against the analyses of history made by eminent West Indian historians such as Williams and Rodney (among others) when we lay blame to the immigrants – whether Portuguese, Indian, Chinese, West Indians or Africans who were all indentured. It was the working of the systems imposed on us by the British, whether political (imperialism), economic (pre-capitalist) or cultural (cultural hegemony), that kept us all in thrall. Today, we are still busy blaming each other for our mess and not questioning whether those bequeathed systems are not still contributing to our problems. And that we should get busy, as a first step, in modifying them to assist in leading to greater equity and justice for all of us.”

Twelve years later, after capitalism’s latest globalised financialised phase has imploded, the travails of “doubly free” labour continues as Britain, Europe and the US blame immigrants who “took away their jobs”.

What will I wake up tomorrow to?

Facebook Comments Box
Tags: African Guyanese ideologuesGuyanaRavi DevROAR of Ravi DevThe labour blame game
Share9Tweet6Share2
ADVERTISEMENT
Ravi Dev

Ravi Dev

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
The Vilification Versus the Vindication of Narendra Modi

The Vilification Versus the Vindication of Narendra Modi

September 19, 2023
Ravi Balgobin Maharaj

Who Should be allowed to represent Trinidad and Tobago; Critique of Miss Grand Int’l Competition

September 25, 2023
Leyland-Chitlall-Roopnaraine

PUT YOUR PROMISES IN WRITING

September 17, 2023
Christine Kangaloo

President Kangaloo reflects the strength of the diaspora

March 25, 2023
Dr. Vishnu Bisram

Guyana Schools & Public Institutions must maintain culturally inclusive environment and treat Indians with Equity

September 28, 2023
Lester Siddhartha Orie

Eulogies of the living Kamla and Rowley

September 28, 2023
Baseless Allegations against Guyana Govt in Race Focused Washington Conference

Baseless Allegations against Guyana Govt in Race Focused Washington Conference

September 28, 2023
PNCR’s Grandstanding in Washington at Afro-Guyanese Meet

PNCR’s Grandstanding in Washington at Afro-Guyanese Meet

September 28, 2023

The most important world news and events of the day.

Get ICDN daily newsletter on your inbox.

ADVERTISEMENT
Indo Caribbean Diaspora News

© 2022 Indo-Caribbean Diaspora News. All rights Reserved

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Terms and Condition

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Columns
  • Letters
  • Community News
  • Opinions
  • Videos
  • Features
  • Editorials

© 2022 Indo-Caribbean Diaspora News. All rights Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In