fbpx
  • Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • Opinions
  • Features
  • Letters
  • Videos
  • Editorials
  • Columns
Ravi-Dev

Was Walton-Desir racist?

May 17, 2021
Bhagwatam for NY Deceased Indian Caribbean in Queens

Bhagwatam for NY Deceased Indian Caribbean in Queens

August 18, 2022
Maha Puran Yagya at Trinidad Sudama Mandir in NY

Maha Puran Yagya at Trinidad Sudama Mandir in NY

August 18, 2022
Steven Alvarez

Focus on the positive!

August 18, 2022
Mandy’s Delicious Caribbean

Mandy’s Delicious Caribbean Queens Black Cake

August 18, 2022
Gandhi’s Statue Smashed to Smitherines at NY Guyanese Mandir

Gandhi’s Statue Smashed to Smitherines at NY Guyanese Mandir

August 18, 2022
Clement Rohee’s

NY Group Supports Rohee’s Appointment at Gecom

August 18, 2022
Pandit Mochand Explains Ramayana

Pandit Mochand Explains Ramayana

August 18, 2022
gandhi-statue

Intolerance against Gandhi in Queens, New York

August 18, 2022
Paras Ramoutar

Reflections on T& T’s Independence

August 17, 2022
Pandit Rishi Misir

Pandit Rishi Misir — Soft Voice, Firm, and Principled

August 18, 2022
Krishna Samaroo

Hariji & Hindu Revivalism in Trinidad and Tobago

August 17, 2022
NY Indo-Caribbeans host Ramayana in the Park

NY Indo-Caribbeans host Ramayana in the Park

August 16, 2022
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Donate
Friday, August 19, 2022
  • Login
Indo Caribbean Diaspora News
  • Home
  • Columns
    Clement Rohee’s

    NY Group Supports Rohee’s Appointment at Gecom

    76th Independence Day of India Celebrated in Guyana

    76th Independence Day of India Celebrated in Guyana

    Dr. Vishnu Bisram

    Guyana Chronicle Praised for acknowledging India’s Independence

    Mr. Rudranath Indarsingh

    INDARSINGH: GOVERNMENT’S EJECTION OF TOBAGONIANS…

    AMBAS DE L'INDE SEP 18 REMISE LIVRE - copie

    Indian Indentureship to Reunion Island, France

    RUDRANATH INDARSINGH

    INDARSINGH CONDEMNS GOVERNMENT INACTION ON SNAIL AND MOSQUITO INFESTATIONS; SAYS GOVERNMENT IS IGNORING PUBLIC HEALTH EMERGENCY.

    Pols Condemn Hate & Attack on Gandhi Statue in Little Guyana

    Pols Condemn Hate & Attack on Gandhi Statue in Little Guyana

    Dr. Baytoram Ramharack

    Genocidal Acts against Indians at Wismar

    USA SELECTS ITS INDIAN BEAUTY QUEENS in PAGEANT

    USA SELECTS ITS INDIAN BEAUTY QUEENS in PAGEANT

    INDARSINGH: CPO OFFER OF 4% ABOMINABLE

    INDARSINGH: CPO OFFER OF 4% ABOMINABLE

  • Letters
    Guyana-map

    Tribute to Mother India

    Steven Alvarez

    Independence of & Freedom in Trinidad and Tobago

    Phillip Alexander

    PNM Political Stunts

    Steve Alvarez

    Emancipation Mamaguy II in Trinidad and Tobago

    trinidad-map

    Objection to West Indies Cricket Team Kneeling

    Steven Alvarez

    Trinibagonians need to elect good managers

    Ravi Balgobin Maharaj

    Disagree with Trinidad Law Assn on AG Armour

    Vassan Ramracha

    Suffering during Slavery & Indentureship in West Indies

    Phillip Edward Alexander

    Gov’t Speaks in Contempt of Black Trinidadians

    Steve Alvarez

    We cannot just sit by and watch our Country Trinidadian & Tobago burn

  • Community News
    Bhagwatam for NY Deceased Indian Caribbean in Queens

    Bhagwatam for NY Deceased Indian Caribbean in Queens

    Maha Puran Yagya at Trinidad Sudama Mandir in NY

    Maha Puran Yagya at Trinidad Sudama Mandir in NY

    Mandy’s Delicious Caribbean

    Mandy’s Delicious Caribbean Queens Black Cake

    Gandhi’s Statue Smashed to Smitherines at NY Guyanese Mandir

    Gandhi’s Statue Smashed to Smitherines at NY Guyanese Mandir

    Pandit Mochand Explains Ramayana

    Pandit Mochand Explains Ramayana

    gandhi-statue

    Intolerance against Gandhi in Queens, New York

    Pandit Rishi Misir

    Pandit Rishi Misir — Soft Voice, Firm, and Principled

    NY Indo-Caribbeans host Ramayana in the Park

    NY Indo-Caribbeans host Ramayana in the Park

    Indo-Caribbean Ramayana in Park Commences in Richmond Hill, NY

    Indo-Caribbean Ramayana in Park Commences in Richmond Hill, NY

    Ramayana in Park in America Concludes

    Ramayana in Park in America Concludes

  • Editorials
    Steven Alvarez

    Focus on the positive!

    Vassan Ramracha

    Freddie not the only one qualified to discuss Guyanese Affairs; praises Drs. Ramharack and Bisram

    Vassan Ramracha

    An Explanation why Hindus Convert

    Jai Lall

    What do you love about Guyana?

    DOMINICA

    DOMINICA RANKS No. 1 ON TRAVEL +

    Harry Hergash

    Oil Extraction, Climate Change, and Security

    Guyana Chess Federation in Courtesy Visit with Indian Ambassador

    Guyana Chess Federation in Courtesy Visit with Indian Ambassador

    trinidad-map

    A Judgment fled to British beasts relating to Trinidad ?

    Left to right: Nicole Catherine Linton, Julie Fletcher, Alice Bigland, Lesley Gosling, Grace Fryer, Tiagan Dealey, Hannah Young, Cara Meikle, Leanne Schembri, Jenna Hurst, Suzanne Wright, Ewa Katarzyna Zachmac, Shenika Ramsay - JTB

    Jamaica Tourist Board Release

    Steve Alvarez

    THE UNPLEASANT TRUTH (of opposition coalition)

  • Opinions
    Paras Ramoutar

    Reflections on T& T’s Independence

    Lester Siddhartha Orie

    Before Rushdie was Another: Enter Siddhartha

    SWAMI PRAKASHANAND

    Hindus, Raksha Bandhan and Smart Schools

    Prahalad Sooknanan

    Fellow Villager Pays Tribute to Hariji

    Sham Moteelall’s Research of the Indentured System

    Sham Moteelall’s Research of the Indentured System

    Dr. Vishnu Bisram

    Guyana should heed message from USA especially on China

    An Assessment of President Ali’s Washington Trip

    An Assessment of President Ali’s Washington Trip

    Dool Hanomansingh

    Our boys and girls are doing fine!!!

    Dool Hanomansingh

    Why the PNM continues to win

    Steve Alvarez

    Challenging Times and Leadership

  • Videos
    Dool-Hanomansingh-003

    US Congress woman Tulsi Gabbard condemns the ongoing genocide of Hindus and other minorities

    Geeta-Vaahini

    Geeta Vaahini, President of the  Hindu Prachaar Kendra speaks on the social significance of Ganga Dhara Festival.

    Geeta-Vaahini

    Geeta Vaahini, President of the Hindu Prachaar Kendra speaks on the Hindu view of the environment.

    swami-brahmadeo

    Swami Brahmadeo – Hindus are top CEOs and Medics in North America and Europe

    Gowtam-Maharaj

    Gowtam Maharaj, a farmer of Barrackpore, South Trinidad, shares his challenges being a farmer.

    BAMBOO #1 Flooding – Frustrated Residents

    BAMBOO #1 Flooding – Frustrated Residents

    NATIONAL-LOTUS-THEATRE

    NATIONAL LOTUS THEATRE – Performance of Niyantran

    radica-jairam

    Story of RADICA JAIRAM from Orange Valley

    fisherman-trinidad

    Families of Orange Valley felt neglected by PNM Government

    Dr Subramanian Swamy

    Dr Subramanian Swamy – Dharma Rising London April 2015

  • Features
    Krishna Samaroo

    Hariji & Hindu Revivalism in Trinidad and Tobago

    India's Independence day

    Marking of the 75th anniversary of India’s Independence

    JAMAICA AND THE CAYMAN ISLANDS SET TO COLLABORATE ON TOURISM

    JAMAICA AND THE CAYMAN ISLANDS SET TO COLLABORATE ON TOURISM

    Pictured: Acting Visitor Relations Manager, Jamaica Tourist Board, Candessa Cassanova presents Captain Leon Missick with gifts following the flight’s arrival into Sangster International Airport.

    JAMAICA WELCOMES THE RETURN OF SERVICE TO MONTEGO BAY BY CAYMAN AIRWAYS

    A section of the audience at the birthday celebration of Hariji.

    Independent Senator praises Hariji

    Dool Hanomansingh

    Hindu Revivalism in Trinidad & Tobago

    Paras Ramoutar

    Build Police Post in Caparo

    Lionel Luckhoo

    Indian Guyanese Sir Lionel Luckhoo

    Guyana-map

    Love of Animal

    Indian South African Honored

    Indian South African Honored

No Result
View All Result
Indo Caribbean Diaspora News
No Result
View All Result

Was Walton-Desir racist?

by Ravi Dev
May 17, 2021
in Columns, Community News
0
Ravi-Dev

Photo : Ravi Dev

6
SHARES
68
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

I have held off to date from commenting on the remarks of Ms Walton-Desir that has precipitated such a heated debate on race and racism in Guyana. On a social media discussion with Dr David Hinds, attempting to explain voter behavior in Guyana, Ms Desir divided them into “PPP voters and PNC voters”. After the storm erupted, Ms Desir asserted that she never spoke about “Indian and African Guyanese”. While she did not do so explicitly, even if Ms Desir were not an attorney who studied defamation, she knows that if ordinary Guyanese listening to her could identify who she was referring to, then it’s rather disingenuous to sustain her denial. So let’s move on.

What did Ms Desir say? Pertinently, that PPP voters are “a bunch of mentally lazy people” for whom, “the burden of sorting things out for themselves is too great” and they remain “trapped and in bondage”. “Contrastingly” she asserted, “supporters of the PNC are far more inquisitive, and enquiring and who have a greater appreciation of the democratic process.” The question therefore, is whether this statement is “racist”? It certainly is since, at a minimum, it attributes an impaired mode of thinking to a whole group of people based on their race (Indian Guyanese). In contrasting this racial group with another racial group, African Guyanese, who she claims are superior in their thinking process, Ms Desir removes all doubt as to her the import of her statement about Indian Guyanese. It was, and is, racist.

The irony is that Ms Desir’s statement on Indian Guyanese is a rather inelegant statement of what political scientists have discovered as far back as the 1960s – but for all voters. Using research drawn from psychology on the limits of rationality when applied in everyday decision making, they came up with the notion of “bounded rationality” and the use of “heuristics” or shortcuts in voter decision making. They explicitly explained that it had nothing to do with being stupid or “mentally lazy” as Ms Desir proposed. Back in the 1990s, Prof Michael Dyson, used the concept as the “Black Utility Heuristic”, to explain Black American voting patterns. He postulated that the heuristic was related to their knowledge of their condition and one of the elements of their heuristic was the acknowledgement of a “linked fate” as a group. From this perspective, their behavior was quite rational. These are matters I have written in extensively over the years to explain Guyanese “ethnic” voting.

All Guyanese, being humans, utilize heuristics to make decisions in politics and in life. I have proposed that because of their lived experience which had sedimented to make them perceive their linked fates ethnically, the structural basis of the heuristic for the major ethnic groups are their “Ethnic Security Dilemmas”. And the “knowledge” that actuated them is embodied in the narratives each group have about themselves and other groups. Ms Desir was merely regurgitating her heuristics from her “people’s” narrative. As I wrote to Vincent Alexander a few months ago in our discussion on the subject, African-Guyanese stressed their “earlier westernization”, of which, Ms Desir’s rationality and democracy ,are integral elements.

I continued that “The Indian-Guyanese narrative, on the other hand, proposed that they saved the sugar industry – and hence Guyana as a viable entity – since a peasant economy could not generate the funds necessary to maintain the hydraulics”. That they remained rural bound to accomplish this task and away from “westernization” longer allowed African Guyanese to inflict epistemic violence on them with they claim that they were “mentally lazy” and “not rational”

So yes, Ms Desir was being racist in her explanation but, in my estimation, not intentionally so. However, since she uttered words that made an entire group of fellow Guyanese feel insulted, her intention does not matter. And in fact it is privileging her as the perpetrator of the racist statement to make that argument rather than focusing on the feelings of the persons who have been harmed.

I conclude with what I had told Vincent: “notwithstanding our several ethnic orientations and truths, we have to craft a common narrative that infuses a Civic Guyanese nationalism to deliver justice and equity through its institutions to all Guyanese.”

We must be careful with our words in Guyana: they have consequences.

Facebook Comments Box
Tags: Guyanaindo-caribbeanIndo-GuyaneseRavi DevTrinidad and Tobago
Share2Tweet2Share1
Ravi Dev

Ravi Dev

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Bhagwatam for NY Deceased Indian Caribbean in Queens

Bhagwatam for NY Deceased Indian Caribbean in Queens

August 18, 2022
Indo-Caribbean Ramayana in Park Commences in Richmond Hill, NY

Indo-Caribbean Ramayana in Park Commences in Richmond Hill, NY

August 16, 2022
Mandy’s Delicious Caribbean

Mandy’s Delicious Caribbean Queens Black Cake

August 18, 2022
Maha Puran Yagya at Trinidad Sudama Mandir in NY

Maha Puran Yagya at Trinidad Sudama Mandir in NY

August 18, 2022
Bhagwatam for NY Deceased Indian Caribbean in Queens

Bhagwatam for NY Deceased Indian Caribbean in Queens

August 18, 2022
Maha Puran Yagya at Trinidad Sudama Mandir in NY

Maha Puran Yagya at Trinidad Sudama Mandir in NY

August 18, 2022
Steven Alvarez

Focus on the positive!

August 18, 2022
Mandy’s Delicious Caribbean

Mandy’s Delicious Caribbean Queens Black Cake

August 18, 2022

The most important world news and events of the day.

Get ICDN daily newsletter on your inbox.

Indo Caribbean Diaspora News

© 2022 Indo-Caribbean Diaspora News. All rights Reserved

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Donate

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Columns
  • Letters
  • Community News
  • Opinions
  • Videos
  • Features
  • Editorials

© 2022 Indo-Caribbean Diaspora News. All rights Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In